Category: Draft Talk

By the OilKnight 01/01/20

With the Oilers drafting Philip Broberg & Evan Bouchard in back to back drafts with their 1st round pick, plus the emergence of prospects like Caleb Jones & Ethan Bear at the NHL level, it’s probably safe to say the Edmonton Oilers won’t be targeting a defenceman with their 1st round selection in the 2020 NHL Draft.

It is possible they could target a goalie like Yaroslav Askarov with this year’s selection, but for the purpose of this exercise I’m going to assume that won’t be the case. 

Before I give you a breakdown of the Top 15 Forwards available in this draft, let’s take a look at the pipeline in Edmonton with my personal assessment on each prospect. 

On defence, the organization is as deep as it’s ever been with promising prospects playing at all levels. Here’s a complete list including my own grades in terms of NHL impact eventually. ETA being when I expect them to be full-time. Ethan Bear (A-), Caleb Jones (B+) and Joel Persson (C) have all played several games on the Oilers already so they are excluded from this list. 

~

Defensive Prospects

A  Evan Bouchard, RD (AHL) – Future top pair RHD and PP quarterback. There will be some growing pains defensively, but he has all the tools to be a high-impact offensive force in the NHL. Smart, poised, excellent puck mover & great offensive instincts. ETA: 2020-2021

B+ Philip Broberg, LD (SWE) – Should be a Top 4 defenceman eventually. Very similar skill-set to Darnell Nurse. Likely not a high-impact offensive force like some hope, but should still be a very effective player. Destined to be future 2nd pair LD. ETA: 2021-2022

B  William Lagesson, LD (AHL) – Skates well, defends well, moves the puck well, plays physical. Not a sexy player stylistically but very effective especially in his own zone. ETA: 2019-2020

B-  Filip Berglund, RD (SWE) – Having watched several Skelleftea games this season, quite often I came away more impressed with Berglund than Broberg. Now, Berglund is 4 years older & a SHL veteran, but he has nice skills that should translate well. He’s a good skater, strong defensively & makes good decisions. He also moves the puck well & has a big shot. 2nd pair possibility. ETA: 2021-2022

B-  Dmitri Samorukov, LD (AHL) – Dima is likely still a couple years away as he transforms into a reliable, stay-at-home, physical defenceman but should be worth the wait. Good puck mover & sneaky good offence but decision making will take time. Bottom 4 D-man. ETA: 2021-2022

C  Michael Kesselring, RD (ECAC) – Much like Samorukov, Kesselring is a big, mobile defenceman with some sneaky good offensive ability. Unlike Samorukov, he doesn’t possess that real nastiness or physical presence but he does move the puck well. Could he be a poor man’s Adam Larsson? Perhaps. Still long ways to go but trending up. ETA: 2023-2024

D+ Philip Kemp, RD (ECAC) – RHD that is a physical stay at home type. Doesn’t offer much in terms of offence but very good in his own zone. Basically, he’s another Matt Benning. Possible #6 but no guarantees he even sticks with this organization. ETA: 2021-2022. 

The one player missing from the rankings we did earlier in the summer is John Marino. Now, I’m not going to say I knew he was going to be a surefire bonafide NHL defenceman, but I did like him a lot & was higher on him than most as I thought he was a promising prospect. 

It’s a shame Edmonton couldn’t get him signed or get more for him but if he didn’t want to play there not a whole lot they could do to change his mind. 

~ ~ ~

Up front, here is where the lack of depth in the organization shows. The forward lines in Edmonton can’t find a legit 2nd line winger to play with Draisaitl or Nugent-Hopkins. There is some talent in the pipeline but no one that projects to be a surefire 30+ goal scorer.  Yamamoto gets his first crack on New Year’s eve and Benson might not be far behind him. But for now, this group is decent but has a lot to prove. 

Forward Prospects

B+ Kailer Yamamoto, RW (AHL) – Potential impact player who needs to stay healthy if he’s going to live up to his 1st round draft status. Excellent skater, strong work ethic & good playmaking skills but rambunctious style + dimunitive frame = health concerns longterm. Edmonton needs him badly right now to produce offensively. ETA: NOW

B+ Tyler Benson, LW (AHL) – Excellent playmaker with good offensive instincts. Lack of speed & explosiveness are concerns though at NHL level but might be able to overcome that with smarts & good positioning. Is going to get his shot in Edmonton very soon. Has the hockey IQ & passing ability to be a top 6 forward if he can keep up. ETA: Next 2 months.

B+ Kirill Maksimov, W (AHL) – A knee injury in March set him back 5 months. Before that, he had 40 goals in 63 games & 74 goals the past two seasons in the OHL. A pure shooter with an NHL shot & release, Maksimov is a natural PP threat but can also play bottom 6 on the penalty kill. He likes to play physical & is a good 200 ft player. Maksimov started slow in the AHL but has picked it up lately. Will take some time, but once it clicks for him watch out. Top 6 winger potential eventually. ETA: 2021-2022

B– Raphael Lavoie, RW (QMJHL) – Another prospect who can really shoot the puck. Lavoie has a big shot & release but struggles to get it off at times. Work ethic & consistency issues are slight cause for concern. Skates pretty well, good offensive instincts, very strong on stick. Very similar to Maksimov though not as polished in 200 foot game. ETA: 2021-2022

C+ Ryan McLeod, C (AHL) – Terrific skater & penalty killer but limited offense limits his ceiling. Never really had a breakout year offensively in OHL. Still considered a perimeter player who loses too many puck battles easily. Will have a role in NHL thanks to skating & 200 foot game but likely nothing more than a bottom 6 role player in NHL. ETA: 2021-2022

C  Matej Blumel, F (CZE) – Pretty good skater with nice hands in tight. Pretty heady player too who is a good 200 foot player. Has a chance to be a solid 3rd liner who can chip in a few goals, play with pace and help on the PK. A workhorse who has been solid for Czechs at World Juniors. ETA: 2022-2023

C- Aapeli Rasanen, C (NCAA) – Crafty center who reads the game well and plays a good 200 foot game. Haven’t seen much of him since his promising showings in previous WJC’s but indications are he’s breaking out offensively for Boston College as their 3rd leading scorer. ETA: 2022-2023

D+ Ostap Safin, W, (ECHL) – Tall, skilled Czech prospect who has battled injuries and inconsistency since coming over to North America in 2017. He’s only 20 yrs old so there’s still time and he has the skill to climb fast, but nothing more than a wildcard at this point. ETA: 2021-2022

D  Cooper Marody, F (AHL) – Not convinced he is an NHL’er at this point. Could carve out a bottom 6 role but not much upside here. Speed certainly is an issue and there’s little flash to his game. Battles hard though so still has a chance. ETA:  2020-2021. 

~

The Rest….

~

Likely career AHL’ers: Joseph Gambardella, Josh Currie, Ryan Malone, Cameron Hebig, Jacob Stukel. 

Longshot prospects: Tomas Mazura, Patrik Siikanen, Skyler Brind’Amour, Maxim Denezhkin, Graham McPhee. 

~

~

Top 15 Forward Prospects

~

So, let’s assume for a moment that Edmonton doesn’t select a defenceman with their 1st round pick. History tells us that in the last 13 NHL drafts, at least 2 defenceman have been taken in the Top 10 every single year. So if we count at least two there, plus another say six or seven in the next 15 picks that’s nine. Let’s also assume Yaroslav Askarov will be chosen by another team as well. So realistically, we could guess that in the first 25 picks (where Edmonton is likely headed), there’s about 10 players that we could rule out. That leaves 15 forwards. If the Oilers end up drafting 25th, they’ll likely get close to the 15th best forward. If they draft 10th, perhaps they snag the 7th or 8th best. And if they win the lottery…….. don’t even think about that right now. 

So here is my own list of the 15 best forward prospects in the NHL draft right and I tried to slot them where I think they will realistically be drafted this time not where I would pick them (so no reaches). Enjoy.

~

Lottery Picks

LW Alexis Lafreniere – Dynamic winger who plays with great determination. Elite playmaker, terrific vision, high hockey IQ, quick hands. Likes to throw his weight around. Skating is good not great. Makes up for it with great positioning and feel for the game. Elite puck skills. 

C Quinton Byfield – Possesses tantalizing size/speed/skill. Excellent skater for his size, surprising agility. Slick hands & underrated passer. Solid 2 way game. Very good at faceoffs. Big body & good at puck protection but not physical at all. Still a bit raw but highest ceiling of any prospect. 

W Lucas Raymond – Highly skilled playmaker who can kind of do it all in the offensive zone similar to Lafreniere. Solid in all areas. A real threat on the PP too. If he was in the QMJHL too he might be pushing for 1st overall. Definitely has Superstar qualities. Lack of ice-time currently might be hurting his stock a bit. 

If the Oilers don’t make the playoffs and are fortunate enough to win a Top 3 selection in the lottery again, they will undoubtedly take Lafreniere at 1st overall. If they get the 2nd pick, Byfield seems likely but I could see them trade down a few slots too.

~

Top 7

C  Marco Rossi – The best all-round center in this draft right now. So dangerous in transition. Defensively sound. Very strong in all 3 zones. So smart with puck rarely makes any major mistakes. Elite vision, hockey IQ & passing ability. Soft hands in tight, very strong on the puck. Underrated shot & release. Will likely win the OHL scoring title in his draft year if he stays healthy. Can do it all. Might be the most pro ready as of today. Late 2001 birthday. Could be #3C in Edmonton opening night next season.

F  Tim Stutzle – The German sensation is an dynamic offensive force capable of beating you with his quickness, his puck skills or both. Can stickhandle in a phone booth. Puck control is tantalizing. Also, he is a high energy player with a great work ethic. Does seem to force plays too much at times similar to a guy like Taylor Hall but hustles back hard on defensive end. He & Draisaitl together would be an absolute treat.

RW Alexander Holtz – Big time shooter and scorer. Might have the best shot in the draft. Nasty release. Underrated playmaker too. Great offensive instincts, defensive game needs some work. Not a speed burner but is a good skater. The exact type of player Edmonton badly needs. A natural goal scorer.

Based on the current standings, a lot would have to go wrong for the Oilers to finish Top 7 worst in the standings at the end of the year. But if they did, they would have a shot at one of these three likely with one still available at #7 assuming D Jamie Drysdale was selected Top 6. All 3 of these players would be excellent fits. 

~

Picks 8-23

C Anton Lundell – He’s one player who might drop due to speed concerns and perceived lower ceiling. Lundell is a smart 2 way center with a big wrist shot. He has great offensive instincts and is sound defensively. Excellent vision and passing ability. He’s not the flashiest player just very smart & efficient. Teams will like him but probably not love him so could be tremendous value if he does in fact drop.

C Dylan Holloway – Haven’t seen a ton of this kid yet but from what I do know they is a lot of tools in his toolbox he just needs to put them altogether. Fast and creative even at high speeds. Similar to Stutzle in that he attacks you with speed & elite stickhandling ability. Aggressive forechecker, good on the cycle. Very good wrist shot & release. Some untapped potential here.

C  Connor Zary – late 2001 birthday who has been at or near the top of the scoring standings in the WHL all year long. Productive, hard-working forward with very good offensive instincts. A “better than the sum of his parts” type player who grows on you the more you watch him. Very quick, reliable, and determined.

RW Dawson Mercer – Big time shooter with a terrific release, Mercer is a sexy prospect to watch but also a reliable one. Works hard in all 3 zones and knows how to put the puck in the net. Also very good puck skills and creativity. Underrated passer. Very good skater. Another late 2001 birthday.

LW Cole Perfetti – PP specialist who possesses a terrific wrist shot that is hard & accurate. Very quick hands in tight. Deadly on shootouts. Capable of making some highlight tape to tape passes. Game away from puck needs work. Not physical at all loses a lot of puck battles. Speed is average. Can be invisible at times. Think Jordan Eberle in terms of a comparison. Highly skilled, but some flaws too means he likely drops in the ‘teens.

LW Rodion Amirov – Bit of a wildcard, but Amirov is a hard-working Russian who has stood at in International tournaments by my eye. Seems to be very smart and has great anticipation. Reads plays very well. Great work ethic. Can also really shot the puck and is a very good skater. Quick hands in tight. Skinny, will need to get stronger. Upside here.

C  Jan Mysak – Another potential sleeper here who has shown really well in International tournaments. He’s quick, smart & and very creative in offensive zone. Very good hands, great vision and passing ability. Another riser.

F  Vasili Ponomaryov – So strong on the puck. Great puck protection, goes hard to the net. High energy type player who doesn’t give up on plays. Exceptional work ethic in all 3 zones. Big shot and release, high hockey IQ. Makes plenty of good decisions. Can dangle. Knows how to score. 

RW Noel Gunler – Highly skilled winger with a booming shot but skating & work ethic concerns will inevitably drop him down the list. Could be a big time scorer at next level but consistency issues will cause hesitation from teams thinking of drafting him.

There’s a lot of talent left over if Edmonton just misses out on a playoff spot or bows out before the 2nd round. My two personal favourites out of this group are in the QMJHL – Dawson Mercer & Vasili Ponomaryev. Both possess the speed/skill/smarts & determination that I love in prospects and both would add some much needed scoring help to the Oilers.

~ ~ ~

Now if the Oilers get to the 2nd round or further in the playoffs, no one will really care about where we draft till June. In any case, here are some of the names that will likely be available at those 24-31 slots:

LW Carter Savoie, LW Antonio Stranges, LW Jake Neighbours, C Mavrik Bourque, C Hendrix Lapierre, RW Tyson Foerster, RW Zion Nybeck, F Kasper Simontaival and a few others I left out.

~ ~ ~

So that’s it for now! I’ll try and add highlights to each of the Top 15 prospects soon so you can put a video to the name and refer back. Stay tuned!

~~~

To comment, please do so via Twitter @TheOilKnight

~

• 

• 

• 

We’re only halfway through the summer but one of the most important tournaments for draft eligible players is just around the corner. Many including myself consider the Hlinka-Gretzky tournament the first real test for the 2020 NHL prospects. It’s a great chance to get eyes on the European players in particular who normally don’t get a lot of exposure, and form an initial opinion on their game and NHL translatable skills. The tournament is being held in the Czech Republic & Slovakia and it starts August 5th and runs through August 10th. 

Last year, three players in particular really stood out in the Hlinka-Gretzky Cup tournament and caught the attention of many draft enthusiasts around the world – Philip Broberg, Vasili Podkolzin & Kirby Dach. All three had outstanding tournaments for their respective countries, and quickly found themselves near the top of many “experts” 2019 NHL Mock drafts. That momentum carried them throughout their draft year as all three were selected in the Top 10 of the NHL entry draft. So needless to say, this tournament IS important. As we’ve seen (especially in the case of Podkolzin), a great first impression can make a lasting one. 

With that in mind, there is tremendous talent in this year’s draft. There are a few glaring exemptions who aren’t eligible technically being late 2001 birthdates, so they are playing in the U.S. Summer Showcase instead. But, overall this tournament it is still a loaded with several potentially high NHL draft picks. Here is a quick breakdown of who to watch for:

 

GROUP A

~

Glaring omissions: Alexis Lafreniere, Justin Barron, Braden Schneider

The OHL is absolutely loaded this year and this team has a heavy dose of OHL players on it’s final roster. Last season, FOUR Canadian-born rookies had 25 goals or more in the OHL and all four were in camp. Sudbury’s Quinton Byfield and Saginaw’s Cole Perfetti were locks to make the team. Windsor teammates Will Cuylle, and Jean-Luc Foudy who had 41 assists to lead OHL rookies, also made the team. Erie’s Jamie Drysdale should be the top CHL defenceman this year and will lead the Canadian squad on defence. He is accompanied by Kitchener’s Donovan Sebrango and the Soo’s Ryan O’Rourke. Saginaw goaltender Tristan Lennox likely gets the starting gig after looking real good in camp. All in all, 8 OHL‘ers on this roster with the big three of Byfield, Perfetti & Drysdale expected to lead the way offensively. A full OHL preview of the top prospects in this year’s draft can be found here.

Two highly touted prospects from the QMJHL weren’t eligible for this tournament – Alexis Lafreniere and Justin Barron. However, Chicoutimi’s Hendrix Lapierre had a great camp and secured a spot on this talented squad. His junior teammate Theo Rochette will also join him as will Shawinigan’s Mavrik Bourque. D Lukas Cormier played his way onto the team and Jérémie Poirier also made the final. Five players total from the QMJHL in total. A full preview of the top prospects for the 2020 draft can be found here. 

Our number one ranked WHL‘er in Kaiden Guhle of Prince Albert, had a strong camp & really proved to be a physical presence on defence. He’ll be joined by Moose Jaw’s Daemon Hunt. Up front, Vancouver’s Justin Sourdif & Edmonton’s Jake Neighbours had excellent camps and should help provide some secondary scoring. The hard working Ridly Greig of Brandon (son of former NHL‘er Mark Greig) secured one of the final spots on the team. Prince Albert’s Ozzy Wiesblatt, Winnipeg’s Connor McClennon, and Seth Jarvis of Portland also A full WHL preview of top prospects for the 2020 draft can be found here. 

This is an extremely talented team who should go as far as their big guns will take them. Quinton Byfield, Cole Perfetti and Jamie Drysdale are all projected Top 10 picks in this year’s NHL draft. This is their first step towards solidifying their rankings. 

The full roster is listed here. 

~

CZECH REPUBLIC

~

The Co-host for this tournament, the Czechs don’t have a lot of highly touted prospects though Jan Mysak might be the closest to 1st round potential at this point. Drafted by the Hamilton Bulldogs in the 2019 CHL Import draft, Mysak has represented the Czech Republic internationally at the U16, U17 & U18’s so he has plenty of tournament experience. Pavel Novak is known as a goal scorer with good speed and could impress. He was drafted by Kelowna 13th overall. Ivan Ivan, who might have one of the strangest names, is also one of the youngest and skinniest prospects in this tournament but has plenty of skill and could be a guy to keep an eye on. He will be playing in Cape Breton of the QMJHL next season. 

If the Czechs are going to have a chance in this tourney, they will have to rely heavily on their goaltending. Nick Malik (son of former NHL’er Marek Malik) and Jan Bednar carry a 2nd-3rd rd grade right now. It appears they’ll have to carry this team if they want to medal. Link to rosters here. 

~

FINLAND

~

Glaring omissions: Anton Lundell, Kasper Simontaival (injured)

With Lundell and Simontaival not playing, there is no doubt everyone’s eyes will be on Aatu Räty. Projected to be a potential #1 overall pick in 2021, Räty is the next big thing coming out of Finland. An absolute wizard with the puck, he already has good size and should do well in this tournament. Samu Tuomaala is also not draft eligible till 2021 but is an excellent skater and loves to shoot the puck. Expect him to pot a few at least. Another exciting player to watch out for is Brad Lambert. The 15 yr old Canadian/Finn is actually not draft eligible till 2022 but has a terrific shot & release along with good poise and vision for his age.

Slick puckmover D Kasper Puutio was the 1st overall pick in the CHL import draft so he’s a guy to keep an eye on. He was drafted by Swift Current of the WHL. Roni Hirvonen should also make a good impression with his solid 2 way game and playmaking ability.

All in all, the Finns are very young but are still very talented. Link to rosters here.

~

SWITZERLAND

~

Glaring omission: Theo Rochette

There’s not a lot to get excited about with this Swiss team especially considering Swiss born C Theo Rochette is actually in Team Canada’s camp. Simon Knak is the most highly rated player for this upcoming draft so he’s the main guy to focus on. He’s got good size, real quick hands and a big shot. He was also a Import draft selection of the Portland Winterhawks of the WHL & has signed so will be playing for them this fall. Plus, he scored a couple dynamite goals last year at the Hlinka-Gretzky so he’s experienced too. Probably one of my favourite sleepers in this tournament. 

D Noah Delemont is another familiar name. He can absolutely fly and is a terrific puck mover. He was drafted 3rd overall by Acadie-Bathurst of the QMJHL and should see plenty of ice time for an underwhelming Swiss team. 

~

GROUP B

RUSSIA

~

After his stellar performance in last year’s World Juniors, there’s no doubt all eyes will be on Russian netminder Yaroslav Askarov. He’s currently projected to be a Top 15 pick in this year’s NHL draft so the pressure is on early to impress. Based on how he was able to shut down a loaded American team at the WJC, he should be just fine.

Vasya Ponomaryov could be this year’s Vasili Podkolzin. He is a strong skater with terrific puck skills and a big shot & release. He also appears to be a highly energetic puck hound. He’s my pick to lead the tournament in scoring. If he doesn’t Daniil Gushchin might. Gushchin is a speedy playmaker and scorer who seems to always be around the puck. He had an excellent showing at Hlinka-Gretzky tourney last year & played in the USHL last season. He is currently ranked as a 1st round prospect while Ponomaryov a 2nd rd prospect. Andrei Bakanov is a huge prospect and is commited to Michigan in 2020 despite being drafted by the Guelph Storm of the OHL in this year’s Import draft. He could surprise.

Bottom line, Russia’s hopes likely rely solely on the shoulders of Askarov. They’ll go as far as he carries them. Roster listed here. 

~

SLOVAKIA

~

Like the Swiss, there’s not a lot to get excited about with this team but they do have home field advantage so maybe someone steps up. Everyone will be watching Martin Chromiak who was recently taken 2nd overall by the Kingston Frontenacs in the Import draft to likely be Shane Wright’s trigger man. He’s a smart player who has a good shot and release. 

Samuel Krajc is a player flying under the radar. He has a good size and skill. He represented Slovakia at the WJC last year and was taken by the Calgary Hitmen of the WHL in the import Draft. 

Oleksii Myklukha is the other intriguing player on this team. Born in Poland, he is a really good skater with dynamite hands and has tore up every league he has played in last couple years. He was drafted in the 2nd round by Rouyn-Nouranda of the QMJHL. 

~

SWEDEN

~

Glaring omissions: Alexander Holtz, Lucas Raymond, Noel Gunler

With Holtz and Raymond backing out and Gunler ineligible to play in this tournament, Zion Nybeck becomes the focal point for Team Sweden. Projected to go in the 1st round of the NHL entry draft, Nybeck is a nifty playmaker and forechecking demon. He has good hands but not sure about the footspeed. Big tourney for him with some other big names absent. 

Emil Andrae and Helge Grans are two defencemen worth watching. Both are excellent skaters and puck movers. Very intrigued by Grans in particular who looks and plays like a pro already. Very smart, heady player.

Jesper Wallstedt is a big goalie who got into a couple games last year at the same tournament. He was drafted by Moose Jaw of the WHL and has talent though the pressure will be on to compete for a medal. 

Still a talented team but missing a couple of their big dogs. Link to rosters here.

U.S.A.

~

Glaring omissions: Antonio Stranges, Dylan Peterson, Tyler Kleven, Ty Smilanic.

Due to the U.S. Summer Showcase going on right before this tournament, the U.S. rarely sends their top prospects to this tourney anyways. That being said, there is some nice talent on this team to keep an eye on. 

Ryan Kirwan, Blake Biondi, Jack Williams, and Alex Gaffney of Muskegon of the USHL are probably the best of the group. Jake Ratzlaff has a nice size, skill combination too. 

No idea how this team will fare as so many good players are missing. Probably a disappointing finish is in the cards. Full roster listed here. 

~ ~ ~ 

To comment please do so via Twitter @TheOilKnight

By the OilKnight 06/22/20

~

The 2020 Draft has come and gone, with 6 new prospects now a part of the Edmonton Oilers organization. There were some controversial picks to say the least, as the Oilers attempted to add some much needed speed & skill to their pipeline. The results were mixed, as were my post pick analysis of them, which seem to trigger several members of our nice little Twitter fanbase. I try to call things like I see them and provide unbiased opinions. Changing my tune AFTER Edmonton drafts a prospect isn’t something I’m going to do. Sorry if it doesn’t make some fans feel all warm and fuzzy but that’s how I roll. I don’t try to be super positive or overly negative – I try and give the readers impartiality by sharing my perspective – good and bad.

that being said, I’ve been doing my own independent scouting for many years now unofficially. However, as far as you the reader is concerned, this is officially the 3rd annual Draft recap for the Oilers since I started my website. If you are interested in my two previous year recaps you can view the 2018 one HERE and the 2017 one HERE. There’s no question I lean towards prospects playing in North America typically, though I have pushed hard for guys abroad like Kravtsov, Bokk & Dorofeyev most recently. I favour smarts, speed & skill, and tend to ignore the flashy or one-dimensional kids who don’t have great work ethics or have questionable decision making. 

So here is my breakdown of each pick, along with who I would have taken based on who was still on the board. My Top 31 list going into this draft is what I based my picks on.

~

DRAFT SUMMARY

~

1st Round (8th overall) Edmonton Oilers select – D Philip Broberg

1st Round (8th overall) The OilKnight selects – RW Cole Caufield or trades down & takes C/RW Philip Tomasino

If you followed me on Twitter leading up to the draft, you know I wasn’t a big fan of the Broberg pick. It wasn’t so much a knock on the player himself, but where he was actually selected. I had other defencemen ranked higher and had Broberg ranked in the 20’s. Doesn’t mean I’m necessarily right or he won’t be a good prospect, but in my unprofessional opinion he wasn’t the best choice at #8. I would have much rather the Oilers took Cole Caufield, who was a goal scoring machine and would have been a nice compliment to McDavid & Draisaitl up front. Or, trade down a bit while acquiring more assets and take my favourite player in the draft Philip Tomasino. Neither of those happened so naturally I’m a bit disappointed. Of course that’s all water under the bridge now as I’m going to cheer like heck for the Big Swede.

Broberg, has a nice mix of size and speed, and has some highlight end to end goals on his resume. The issues I had with him was his questionable decision making and penchant for bad turnovers. I watched a ton of film on him leading up to the draft, and saw all of his tournament games this season. I feel like he could be a very good 2nd pair defenceman in the NHL one day, but I’m not sure that he possess enough elite qualites to be a true #1 or #2. Again, it’s just my opinion. I set a ceiling on his upside based on what I’ve seen personally, I hope he destroys that out of water and will be rooting for him hard to do so. But I’m NOT going to blow smoke and say he’s a guaranteed future #1 stud D-man just not to hurt your feelings. Sorry. There is talk he could play for Hamilton in the OHL next season which would be awesome as I could track his development up close. Fingers crossed. 

~ ~ ~

2nd Round (38th overall) Edmonton Oilers select – C/W Raphael Lavoie

2nd Round (38th overall) The OilKnight selects – D Vladislav Kolyachonok

At this point in the draft, there were several defencemen I really liked that were still on the board: Kolyachonok, Matthew Robertson & Samuel Bolduc in particular. Seeing I would have taken a forward in the 1st round in my mock, I definitely would have took defence with this pick. Kolyachonok would have been the choice as I am a huge fan of his 2 way game. I’ve been extremely high on the Belarusian all year and was probably the only one in the world who had him as the 2nd best defenceman in this draft. Huge upside. 

Pavel Dorofeyev would have also been a great pick in my opinion had I stuck with another forward here. The Oilers however chose to go a different route and selected Raphael Lavoie of the QMJHL. Lavoie, has an elite shot and release first and foremost. His top end speed is solid. He also has nice playmaking ability. He had a monster playoff for Halifax this past season. The issues I have with him were his decision making – especially shot selection. Quite often he would skate into traffic or shoot when the pass was there. He quit moving his feet a lot and too often settled for a low percentage shot. Offensive zone turnovers were also an issue. Plus, he’s almost older than every other prospect having just missed last year’s draft by 10 days. But, there’s no doubt he has a lot of talent and if paired with McDavid or Draisaitl he could be a real nice find here. Either way, I wasn’t big on him in the 1st round but similar to last year when the Oilers took Ryan McLeod, Lavoie provides great value in the 2nd round. 

~ ~ ~

3rd Round (85th overall) Edmonton Oilers select – G Ilya Konovalov

3rd Round (85th overall) The OilKnight selects – RW Maxim Cajkovic

I gotta admit, this one stings a bit. I REALLY like Maxim Cajkovic as a sleeper this year. Similar to Philipp Kurashev who was my favourite sleeper last year, Cajkovic has a ton of talent and could explode next season with better teammates around him. He has an elite NHL shot & release, is an excellent skater & works hard on the ice. He developed a few bad habits playing on a miserable team but those are all correctable in my view, as he matures as a player. I would have loved it if he was the pick here. 

The Oilers instead, took a Russian goalie out of the KHL. Now, I admit I knew nothing about Konovalov at the time he was drafted. Doing some research following the selection, I can see the appeal he had for the Oilers. He was named KHL rookie goalie of the year. Plus, his numbers in the KHL were staggering at first: 48 GP, 1.89 GAA, .930 SV%, that is until you realize that only put him 7th & 9th in the league overall in those categories. Upon further review, the KHL only had TWO players with more than 25 goals in the league in a 62 game season. Not exactly, a elite scoring league. 10 goalies with a minimum of 20 GP had a GAA of under 2.00. So his numbers are a bit misleading. Also, Konovalov is an overager and is listed only at 6’0″. Not too many goalies in the NHL are that “short” so there is a bit cause for concern there but that doesn’t automatically mean he won’t be a hit. Plus, if you combine him with Mikko Koskinen who is huge, it evens out anyways. It’s a gamble as a 3rd rd pick. Interesting side note, the team Konovalov plays for will be coached by the recently dismissed –  Craig MacTavish. 

~ ~ ~

4th Round (100th overall) Edmonton Oilers select – F Matej Blumel

4th Round (100th overall) The OilKnight selects – LW Ethan Keppen

This was another big miss in my mind in the 4th round. Call me crazy, but 30 goals in the OHL at age 17 is better than 30 goals in the USHL at age 18. That’s exactly what we’re looking at when comparing Keppen with Blumel. Yes, Blumel has excellent speed but he only had 8 goals, 10 assists for 18 points last year – his actual draft year. Give Ethan Keppen another year how impressive will his numbers be? This could still turn out to be a decent pick but the USHL isn’t even close to OHL competition in my opinion so I have my doubts. 

~ ~ ~

6th Round (162nd overall) Edmonton Oilers select – F Tomas Mazura

6th Round (162nd overall) The OilKnight selects – F Martin Lang

I’m not going to lie, I would have took Czech import Martin Lang from Kamloops of the WHL here even though he ultimately went undrafted. I liked him more than most people going in. I was very impressed with him at the Hlinka-Gretzky and World Juniors where I thought he was one of the Czech Republic’s best players. His transition to North American game has been a bit difficult, but I saw enough in flashes to think he could be a really good prospect one day. Plus, he is literally the YOUNGEST player in this draft with his birthday being on the exact day of the cut-off. Picks this far into the draft are complete crapshoots anyways, but I would have took Martin Lang. 

The Oilers selected F Tomas Mazura who’s best friend apparently is their 4th round pick – Matej Blamel. I admit, I didn’t know much about Mazura either when he was selected. He played at Kimball Union Academy of the USHS-prep league where he was their leading scorer (27th in league overall). He’s a big kid looks like and is regarded as a playmaker apparently but I’ve never seen him play for a second to date, so I have no opinion on him. He is almost a full year older than Lang though. He is committed to Providence in the fall. 

~ ~ ~

7th Round (193rd overall) Edmonton Oilers select – F Maxim Denezhkin

7th Round (193rd overall) The OilKnight selects – G Dustin Wolf

Hey look, another guy that will be playing for Craig MacTavish in the KHL next season! I find it hilarious that one of the OBC members in MacTavish supposedly walked away but is now all of the sudden in charge of developing TWO of Edmonton’s prospects now. How ironic. I have no idea if Denezhkin will be a good player or not but I’m sure MacT will do his best to give the kid as much ice time as possible so maybe this turns out to be a sleeper pick. 

Seeing the Oilers were OK with taking a 6’0″ goalie, I would have waited and just took Dustin Wolf in the 7th round. Why? For one, he had outstanding numbers in the WHL: 61 GP,1.69 GAA, .936 SV%. Second, he is 3 years younger than Konovalov. Gimme a kid with those numbers and room to grow physically over the 21 year old unknown any day.

~ ~ ~

RECAP

~

I consider myself a very positive person in general, and try to be on Twitter when it comes to discussing the Oilers. I don’t take things too seriously usually but when it comes to scouting prospects – I do. In my opinion, and take it with a grain of salt if you must, this was a disappointing draft for the Oilers. Not because they didn’t take my guys, but because outside of the Lavoie pick, I feel they didn’t take the best player available.

The Oilers badly needed forwards in the pipeline that could score goals. They have plenty of D-men already with good upside, but who in the organization is ready to step in score at the forward position in a couple years? Kirill Maksimov is the only pure shooter they have. They badly need more and passed on some good ones at #8. The difference between Broberg and a Kolyachonok who went 2nd round is slim if anything in my mind. Caufield had 86 goals last year. He could have filled a huge void in the organization but they decided to go a different route which I think was a mistake.

The Oilers also drafted two buddies from schools that rarely, if ever, produce NHL talent. One is already 19 yrs old and underwhelmed badly in his draft year last year while the other turns 19 soon. Then they drafted two guys who are playing for Craig MacTavish who was supposedly let go but clearly will be playing a vital role in player development.

Overall, I hate to say it but it was a very underwhelming draft for me. Broberg will be an NHL‘er I’m just not sure of his upside. I am really excited to see him live though hopefully. Lavoie is a boom or bust prospect. Plenty to like but plenty of concerns as well. The rest are complete wildcards who may never even get close to the NHL. Again, it’s just my opinion I hope I am completely wrong about all of them – but I doubt it. There’s plenty to be excited about with this upcoming NHL season but for me, this draft class isn’t one of them.

~

To comment please do so via Twitter @ TheOilKnight